Some rough work and notes made for SYP

During the course of SYP I kept a file on the desktop of my computer into which I would file different notes that I had made about different lines of enquiry I intended to run down such as this list of photographers and artists I was curious about that I wanted to investigate further.  I didn’t always get around to it but some day I hope I will.  Sometimes when researching an a piece of work I would use text edit to make notes, pulling images from a website and scribbling my initial thoughts on them like this.

At various stages of the course while resolving my major project I would brainstorm ideas for images that might fit into the set like this or this 

Feedback on Assignment 1 from Linda Shevlin

Linda Shevlin is independent curator in residence at Roscommon Arts centre.  She was the very first person I approached for feedback on my work and she was kind enough to look over the document that I created for assignment 1.

On the 30th of August 2016 I sent her this email:

Dear Linda

I attended your Martin Parr exhibition a few weeks ago and I wanted to first of all say that I really enjoyed it and was impressed by the Arts centre itself.  I am an artist originally from Dublin but living in Easkey Co. Sligo.  I am currently completing a BA in photography with the Open College of the Arts.  It’s a distance learning course and I am currently undertaking the final module.  I have been working on a body of work titled There’s No Place like Home and I am currently looking to people working in the arts in Ireland who might be willing to give me some feedback on it.  As I am sure you understand feedback is vital in the creation process, art is about public communication and visual art is made to be shown not stored safely on a hard drive.  Would it be o.k to send you a PDF file with an edited version of the work, an artists statement and a bio and ask you for your feedback as a curator? 
Best Regards
Brian Cooney 
She replied shortly afterwards:
Hi Brian

My apologies for the delay in replying, I’m in Australia at the moment installing an exhibition.
Sure, send on a PDF and I’ll give you some feedback.
Best
Linda
Her feedback on the work was invaluable and lead me to reassess the work and the artists statement.  This is what she wrote about what I sent her:
Hi Brian

My apologies. It’s been a very busy time for me and I just didn’t get the chance to respond to you. I don’t generally do unsolicited feedback as I genuinely find it difficult to respond to work I haven’t seen by an artist I don’t know so again, my apologies as I wasn’t sure how to approach this.
I feel there are some strong images in this collection and others that compositionally need a little work. Again, without seeing them printed and what format they’ll be presented in, it’s hard to tell what the finished product will look like.
Conceptually, you’re working in similar territory to a number of photographers and could try to find a way of setting yourself apart from them in some way. If you are going to show the less Utopian representation of the west then I think you need to push the aesthetic a little more, make it more garish, more crass, more vulgar if you dare!
If you do show them somewhere let me know and I’ll be able to make a more informed response to the work. But in the mean time I hope that’s useful!
All the best
Linda

Pictures From Home by Larry Sultan

Just working my way slowly through this photo book and reflecting on the text.  Quite a lot if the images I had seen before but there are quite a lot I haven’t.  The book is a kind of memoir of his family life narrated by him and also by his parents.  The accompanying text and its relationship with the images creates an interesting context for the work and without spelling everything out plainly also exposes the hidden currents that underlay all family relationships.  What family dynamic can be summed up simply?

We get a sense of the complexities of Sultan’s relationship with his father “It was on these walks that my father told me stories about his childhood, the orphanage, his clubhouse, going out with girls.  I was fourteen years old.  Sometimes his hand would brush the back of my head”  (Sultan.  2017, p 87).  Its interesting too that he regularly compares himself to his father, both showing us photos of them side by side at a similar age.  Photography and Sultan’s obsession with documenting his parents has created a divide between him and his father too.  His father criticises his portrayal of his mother and Sultan replies that he doesn’t seek to glamourise his mother pointing out that in his opinion “In almost every picture of her that he has taken she is posed like a model selling one thing or another” His father feels however ” you have some stake in making us look older and more despairing than we really feel”  (Sultan.  2017, p 23)

Observations on a rubics cube

rubics cube landscape

I had this rubric’s cube made using some typically romantic landscape images of scenery in Ireland.  The type of scenery that is considered beautiful – and perhaps it is – I was thinking after receiving it how beauty is one of those culturally specific qualities that is learnt, inherited and how no-one perceives these scenes as beautiful on their own, they have to be taught to believe this is beauty.  Also these are signifiers for nature – or what we believe is nature – again another culturally specific quality or attribute like the idea of landscape.

I was thinking about the way this puzzle involves assembling these scenes and also disassembling them and how in a strange way the constituent parts of the images are interchangeable.  Now that my son has got his hands on the cube and turned everything around several times I cannot reassemble the original images and this seems quite appropriate.  Also I was reflecting that I have created an object, a sort of an icon.

I have no idea where this is leading.  Its just series of observations reflecting on something that I felt compelled to do some time ago.

Portfolio Review with Angel Luis Gonzalez

Notes from Portfolio review with Angel Luis Gonzalez (Director of PhotoIreland) 16th November 2016

I began by explaining that No Place Like home is a piece that is deliberately ambiguous because I wanted to allow the viewer to form their own narrative from the images.  

Angel began by saying that there were some strong images in the set but that overall he felt the set lacked a sense of unity.  It might be interesting to look at whether the full edit has a greater sense of unity than the selection I sent to him.  He mentioned that perhaps I needed to sharpen up the edit and perhaps even consider killing some of my darlings.  He said that i n the selection of images that I had forwarded to him that there was a lot going one.  

In comparison he brought up Does Yellow Run Forever by Paul Graham, saying that there were only 3 or 4 narrative conversations going on in this body of work.  He felt that as presented there were too many narrative conversations that were going on and that I should simply.

He mentioned that perhaps I should consider looking again at my edit and find associations between images, he specifically mentioned the image of the waterfall sign and felt that in the set presented that it stood alone and needed something to link to it.  He mentioned that I should try not to force an idea but just present it.  He mentioned that I might consider including some tourist locations such as interpretative centres. 

We discussed the idea of the photographer as story teller and that as a story teller it was necessary to tell an interesting story.

He mentioned Miriam O’Connor and felt I should look at her work as well as the work of Paul Graham and Martin Parr.  Also Daragh McGrath.  We discussed representation of place through tourism and specifically photographing in tourist locations such as interpretative centres.  Also he mentioned souvineers and wondered if I could link between Ireland and the rest of the world by using souvenirs manufactured elsewhere.  In this regard the mentioned Philip Toledo’s work on Abu Grahib and Guantanamo.  

Assessment submission part 3

The work created for my major project is about landscape and identity (among other things).  It is about representing Ireland.  Early in my research for my extended written project I came across Catherine Nash’s Remapping and Renaming New Cartographies of Identity, Gender and Landscape in Ireland.  In it she discusses the work of Kathy Prendergast, an Irish artist who’s practice is concerned with gender and geography and who utilises maps in some of her work.  Since reading it I have been interested in the link between what we refer to as landscape – an arbitrary genre of photography – and cartography and mapping.

Both landscape and cartography concern themselves on a surface level at least with how the land is pictured but they are about far more than that.  Issues such as ownership and land use – to name but two – lurk beneath this surface impression.  In the case of Ireland – the place – what usually comes to mind inside my head at least when I hear the word is the green map that resembles a figure reaching an arm out into the Atlantic.  Always green, Ireland has been deliberately branded as a pure and natural place.  In the 1950’s it was John Hinde’s postcards but today with the wild atlantic way we have reached new levels of sophistication in portraying the Island of Ireland as some hyperreal adventure playground that has nothing to do with the lived experience of life in Ireland.

At the same time as all of this sophisticated marketing is being pushed out we also find that there are more and more environmental issues and short comings that date back many years.  Usually these are in direct contrast to the represented hyperreal ireland that is projected by the tourist board.  For instance there is an ongoing issue with waste water and sewage all around the country which is regularly a feature of the Enviromental Protection Agency.  Perusing their extensive website I came a cross a report which featured the two maps of Ireland that feature below.  I have turned both into souvenirs.  These maps features on some tote bags and fridge magnets that I have had made for assessment submission.

areas discharging waste waterurban waste water map

In addition to the maps I have also been experimenting with using images and text combined and turned into a series of fridge magnets.  Some use straight forward image with text such as Ireland, the image of the map is unadorned but for others I have used typical Irish sayings such as – may the road rise up to meet you – or, directly inspired by Nostalgia for the Future by John Kippin – Yeats Country.  The image and text combination work to say something more than either could do alone and then given that these are designed as souvenirs I hope to cause someone pause for reflection.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Finally I have had postcards created from the work exhibited in Ballina.  I chose certain images and designed a logo that eventually became the title of the entire presentation – or re-presentation.

unpackingireland

The title of the piece is Unpacking Ireland.   Once I had created all of the different items I had to think about how I was going to ship them for unpacking at the assessment.  A plain cardboard box seemed all wrong.  As my work is connected with the tourist representation of Ireland I thought maybe an old steamer trunk but this wasn’t possible for reasons of practicality – too expensive and too bulky.  A suitcase seemed like a good idea but it had to be the right suitcase.  Any old suitcase just wouldn’t do.  While searching around on the internet for ideas I remembered reading about how the less well off travellers would often use cardboard suitcases and began to look at some of these.  It seemed practicable as it would be light for postage and the one I eventually found seemed about the right size to house my new collection and would make for an interesting presentation (I hope) at assessment.

These souvenir tea towels, fridge magnets, the photo book, the snow globes, the real ireland calendar were all packing inside and in addition I have placed an artists statement with them to help contextualise the work.  Also the suitcase struck me as a metaphor that was very apt for tourist photography.  Tourist photography takes something, say for example a place, and compresses it down from three dimensions to two and conceals all of the issues, the complexities etc. beneath a surface veneer that conceals more than it reveals.

 

Assessment submission Part 2

The second idea I had was to use images from the series but also from my archive to create a souvenir calendar like the myriad of kitsch calendars that can be seen for sale in many tourist shops around Dublin.  In fact I decided to call it The Real Ireland Calendar after seeing one with that title filled with the usual imagery of Ireland in a shop.

As I was putting it together I was reminded of the seasonal portfolio exercise from my level 2 Landscape course and how initially when I began to think about the wild Atlantic way and tourism in the west it was the seasonal nature of such tourism that stood out for me.  So I thought I would structure the images on a sort of seasonal basis.

I also used, as I said, images from my archive, sometimes single images that I had no context to place within previously but that fit here.

I am reasonable happy with the finished article although I am not sure if there aren’t too many repetitive images within it.  There are a lot of images of tourists taking photographs and I do wonder now having seen the finished calendar if it mightn’t be a good idea to explore and include more variety.

Again as per the previous post I am not sure where I would use this, initially I am thinking pop up gift shop in conjunction with an exhibition.

The main learning to take away from this?  Using the archive can be quite productive.  A work is perhaps not really finished just put aside for a while before one returns to it to continue the dialogue.  Its a different way to use photography, a different context in which to employ it to help a viewer reflect and think.  Also it has occurred to me that I have been thinking about and working on this project for longer than I realised and that sometimes the images arrive before the idea or the context in which to use them.

 

Assessment submission part 1

As part of assignment 5 I mentioned to my tutor that I would be submitting something a little different.  My idea was to use some of the images to create a series of tourist souvenirs.  This idea was originally proposed by Angel Luis Gonzalez who pointed me to Phillip Toldano’s work American Gift Shop.

Initially it was just an idea, I didn’t really see how it would come together but I felt I had to follow through on it.  I began with an idea to create some snow globes using my images from my main project.  I bought the first of these online but was unhappy with the quality so I returned them.  Then I found a shop in Ballina that made me 4 very nice snow globes by printing and inserting my images into them.  Once I had ordered the first pieces I started to think about how these would look to someone else (like an assessor) and I realised I would have to find some sort of packaging to place them in.  Luckily I found the perfect thing, a nice self assembled cardboard box, the right size and an additional green sleeve to go over it.  I also decided to wrap them in green tissue paper inside the box so as to augment the experience of opening them.

With the finished articles sent for assessment I feel I have created something that will help a viewer reflect and think, perhaps question?  I have also stimulated a lot of ideas for myself.

I feel that this work is not complete, I have no firm idea how I will use this experience in the future yet, initially my idea would be to show these pieces alongside an exhibition of the work, perhaps in a pop up souvenir shop?

The main thing I think I learned from this experience is to trust my intuition, there is no such thing as making a mistake, even if this had been a complete failure it stimulated my mind and gave me ideas.  Also the greatest thing I have learnt I feel is to trust in and focus on the process and allow the results to look after themselves.  Also I am looking for other ways, other media besides straight photography that I may use in the future to get my point across to an audience.  I feel I have branched out into an interesting and rewarding area of development and research that may lead somewhere new.

Once the pieces were made and the other articles, which I will post about separately, were created I began to get other ideas.  For instance it occurred to me that I was making objects from photographs and that photography itself has long been guilty of objectification.  Also symbols and the way they are used have become a line of enquiry for me now, for instance how the map of Ireland has itself become a signifier for more than just a geographical place, it is a signifier for nature, for purity and tradition.  Also the colour green.

I shared the video’s with my tutor who suggested that I add a sort of a leaflet inside each one and also that I take all of my souvenirs and create a catalogue with them.  I haven’t had tie to get around to the second one but I did include this leaflet and some different versions of it with the finished items.

to embrace the wild atlantic way

 

Land of Hearts Desire

All of the images and text were contributed by Irish people living outside Ireland.  The diaspora has always had an important role to play in shaping the image of Ireland.  I sent the following message to some of my friends:

Dear …..,

I am putting my final year show together for my degree in photography. The title of the show I have in mind will be Land of Hearts Desire. It comes from a play by Yeats, ostensibly about the west of Ireland but to me its the perfect description for how I felt about Ireland when I lived in France, it was always home no matter how much I loved my new home. One component I would like to include is the perspective of Irish people who live overseas and their perceptions and/or memories of home, both good and/ or maybe not so good. I want to approach as many people like yourself as possible and ask them to contribute an image that means something special, that reminds you of a special place in Ireland that keeps that connection alive. It could be recent or an old image, one you’ve taken yourself or taken by someone else like a relative. And if you’re like me, it wont be a super high quality image taken by a pro, its probably a snapshot that brings to mind a certain time and place, maybe who ever was with you. Perhaps something springs to mind straight away? It could even be a description of a memory with no photo at all. If you have an image that you’d give me permission to use you can send me a digital copy and if I use it I will credit you in any book or exhibition or whatever comes about as a result. Thanks in advance!

 

Contributors:

Nuala Mahon

Joanne Mulvihill-Allen

Aoife Glynn

Louise O’Reilly

Paula Mc Cabe

Larry Higgins

Paul Swail

Aileen Rice

Mark Downey

Fiona Kearns